Multi-Lines Claims Representative

Catholic Mutual Canada

Buffalo, NY

Job ID#:
12949173337
Posted:
January 28, 2026
Expires:
March 29, 2026
Category:
Insurance
Terms:
Full-Time Employee
Experience:
2-5 Years
Education:
Undergraduate Degree
Base Pay:
Salary
For your privacy and security, when applying for a job, never provide your social security number, credit card number or bank account information to a prospective employer. To use this website, you must accept and comply with our Terms of Service.

Job Description

Catholic Mutual Group (CMG), established in 1889, is the leading provider of property, liability, and employee benefit coverage and related services for the Catholic Church throughout the United States and Canada. We are currently seeking experienced insurance professionals to fill two existing Multi-Lines Claims Representative vacancies in our Toronto Service Office.

Position Overview
The Multi-Lines Claims Representative is responsible for receiving, investigating, and adjusting claims while providing exceptional service to our members. This role works closely with the Operations Manager to ensure fair and equitable claim resolution. Responsibilities include verifying coverage, collecting repair estimates or contractor bids, and making recommendations regarding settlements and payments. The position also supports insurance and risk management programs for the Archdiocese.

Key Responsibilities
• Receive, investigate, and adjust property and liability claims
• Perform onsite Risk Inspections
• Facilitate fair and equitable claim settlements
• Verify coverage and gather necessary documentation, estimates, and bids
• Provide recommendations regarding claim settlement or payment
• Maintain positive relationships with assureds and respond to service needs
• Collaborate with the Operations Manager on insurance and risk management programs
• Manage multiple projects simultaneously in a fast-paced environment

Qualifications
• Bachelor's degree or completion of insurance courses such as IIA General Insurance (required)
• Minimum of three years of claims adjusting experience
• General understanding of insurance, marketing, and communications
• Strong verbal and written communication skills
• Ability to manage multiple priorities with strong organizational skills
• Proficiency with telephone-based communication and customer service
• Ability to work effectively both independently and collaboratively
• Bilingual in English and French preferred

Benefits
• Competitive starting salary
• Excellent benefits and paid time off package
• Family-friendly, employee-centered work environment
• 35-hour work week; hybrid work schedule

Pay range for this position: $88,616 to $110,770 per year.

Apply online: https://www.catholicmutual.org/Careers

Catholic Mutual Group is an equal opportunity employer.

About the Employer

As a part of the Catholic Church, Catholic Mutual is the leading provider of property, liability and employee benefit coverage and related services for the Catholic Church in North America, currently serving more than 134 Dioceses and Archdioceses and over 200 Catholic religious orders and institutions in the United States and Canada. www.catholicmutual.org